“Three Identical Strangers” was released in 2018 and follows the story of three identical triplets who were separated at birth, and later reunited. The three triplets were placed up for adoption at six months old, and the three were placed in different homes with varying socioeconomic statuses. The adoptive parents were never informed that the children were triplets. The three brothers were all placed in homes that also had an older adopted sister. After 19 years of not knowing one another the union came with much excitement, and they quickly became media sensations. They focused heavily on the various similarities they had with another, and fully emerged themselves with their new-found brotherhood. The ultimately moved in together and opened up a restaurant. However, over time the differences between the three became very apparent, and a common theme of mental health became very prevalent among the group. Ultimately one of the three triplets committed suicide in 1995.
After many questions were simply unanswered, a deeper look was placed on the circumstances surrounding the adoptions. The three boys were adopted through the Louise Wise adoption agency, which at the time placed Jewish children in appropriate homes. Once they took a deeper look, they found that multiple sets of twins and triplets were placed in different homes and were observed for years by researchers who often made home visits. The adoptive parents were told it was a standard adoption practice to track the children’s progress. Their entire life had been an experiment entangled in a web of lies. The shocking documentary really raises the question of nature vs nurture and what that looks like in a real-life example. The brothers were raised in very different households and their paths varied differently in the long run. For the first time we are forced to see that nurture could in fact beat nature. As we all know this experiment was beyond unethical, and no one was ever aware that I was just that. An experiment that took no consideration of the many lives it altered. To this day, we still do not know how many other sets of twins could be out their unaware of this ugly truth.